Best versatile prime lens for a Panasonic Lumix S5II?

Question

So I finally picked up the S5II and now I need a solid prime but honestly Im stuck. I keep seeing people recommend the Lumix 35mm f1.8 as the perfect all-rounder but then I read some threads saying the 50mm is better for that classic look and the 35 gets weird distortion for close-up portraits.

My logic was that I could just crop in on the 35mm if I had to but then I lose that shallow depth of field. Im heading to Kyoto next month and I really want to travel light with just one lens. I have about 600 bucks left for this gear. Is there something Im missing or should I just flip a coin between these two?

MichaelWholi · Accepted Answer

Honestly, for a trip like Kyoto, I'd probably play it safe and go with the 35mm. Ive used the Panasonic Lumix S 35mm f/1.8 S-S35 and its a very reliable choice for street stuff and tight temple spaces where a 50mm feels way too cramped. Youre right about the distortion if you get right in someone's face for a headshot, but for general travel, it stays pretty clean and predictable. The Panasonic Lumix S 50mm f/1.8 S-S50 is definitely better for that classic bokeh look, but you might find yourself backing into walls in Japans narrower streets trying to fit a whole building in the frame. Both lenses fit your $600 budget easily. Since theyre part of the same series, they even weigh the same, which is great for carrying it all day. I think the 35mm is the safer bet for travel because you can always crop in, but you cant always walk backward through a wall. Let me know if you need more info on the autofocus or anything else.

Lens Rumors

Forum

Best versatile prime lens for a Panasonic Lumix S5II?