My kit lens is finally dying and I need something sharper for street photography in London. Im tight on cash, maybe 300 quid max. Im torn between the TTArtisan 27mm and the XC 35mm. The AF on the XC is tempting but that pancake size is sweet... which one would you pick?
Re: Honestly, id be really careful about jumping into... totally agree. The Fujifilm Fujinon XC 35mm f/2 is sharp and reliable, but honestly the Fujifilm Fujinon XF 27mm f/2.8 R WR is just magic for street.
If you want reliability, check out the Viltrox 23mm f/1.4 or maybe a used Sigma 30mm f/1.4 DC DN. Both are sharper than the XC and worth every penny tbh.
> that pancake size is sweet... which one would you pick? Honestly, the pancake form factor is a massive trade-off for street work. In my experience, you sacrifice significant corner sharpness and micro-contrast once you push past f/5.6. If you want a real workhorse, you should look into the Samyang AF 12mm f/2.0 X or the Tokina atx-m 23mm f/1.4 X. I have used a ton of glass over the years and the optics on the Tokina are basically rebranded Viltrox internals but with better quality control, which matters a lot when you're shooting in the city. Before I drop more technical data on you, what body are you actually running? The older X-Trans sensors handle third-party glass differently than the newer 40MP sensors, and I dont want to steer you toward something that wont resolve well on your specific camera. Just let me know what you're working with.
Saving this whole thread. So much good info here you guys are awesome.
Late to the party but regarding what #2 said about that Fuji glass, reliability is key for street work since you dont want to be fiddling with firmware updates while the light is changing. If you really want that sharp, clinical look, stop looking at the cheap pancakes. They usually have heavy field curvature and corner softness that you just cant fix in post. I actually spent all yesterday evening recalibrating my old manual focus prime with a set of shims because the flange distance was off by like 0.05mm. Honestly, taking apart your own lenses to adjust the focus helicoid is a nightmare if you dont have a steady hand and the right tools. One wrong move and you strip the tiny internal screws forever. People think DIY repair is saving money until they ruin the glass element coatings. Anyway, just stick to something native if you value your sanity.
TL;DR: Gear prices are totally out of control and it feels like we are all just beta testers for half-baked tech now. ^ This. Also, honestly its ridiculous how much they expect us to pay for decent glass these days. I remember when a solid prime was actually affordable, but now everything feels like a massive compromise between build quality and just getting the thing to focus. It drives me crazy how companies just push these lenses out the door with zero QC and expect us to deal with the headache. I have been shooting with the same gear for years because I am just so tired of the upgrade cycle and these plastic lenses that feel like toys. It is such a scam how they charge premium prices for gear that barely lasts a few seasons. I am genuinely happy with my old setup, but sometimes I look at these new releases and just wonder who they are even for anymore. Honestly, dont even get me started on the firmware updates that break more than they fix. Hope you find something that actually lasts.
Honestly, id be really careful about jumping into third-party glass if youre doing street stuff in London. I used to think saving a few quid was smart until my autofocus decided to take a permanent holiday right in the middle of a shot I really needed. It was super frustrating and honestly left me stranded with a useless hunk of metal. My current setup is solid because I stopped taking chances on lenses that felt a bit too cheap to be true. After that whole mess, I learned a few things the hard way:
- Check the build quality in person first if you can.
- Make sure the focus motor isnt gonna die after six months.
- Weather sealing matters more than people think when you are walking around the city. I ended up grabbing one that was a bit more reliable, even if it meant saving for an extra month or two. Reliability is everything when you are out on the street and you only get one chance to capture the moment. Take my advice, dont rush into something just because its cheap. You might want to consider how often you are gonna be using it, because replacing a faulty lens is way more expensive than just buying something that works right the first time...