Just picked up an R8 for my trip to Iceland next month and realized my current kit lens is way too tight for those massive landscapes. Im debating between the Canon RF 16mm f/2.8 and the RF 15-30mm. Budget is around 600 bucks. Is the extra zoom range worth the higher price or should I just stick with the prime and save cash for excursions?
Honestly, grab the Canon RF 16mm f/2.8 STM. Over the years, I've realized that in Iceland, you really want that extra cash for gas and food. The prime is tiny, sharp enough for travel, and fits easily in a jacket pocket. The zoom range on the Canon RF 15-30mm f/4.5-6.3 IS STM is nice, but for that price, I'd rather spend the savings on a nice glacier hike. Safe travels!
Late to the party but honestly, I found the optical performance of both these lenses a bit lackluster for high-resolution sensors. If you go with the Canon RF 16mm f/2.8 STM, expect significant distortion that requires heavy software correction, which unfortunately eats into your effective resolution. The Canon RF 15-30mm f/4.5-6.3 IS STM offers more utility, but the variable aperture is not as good as expected for low-light shots at dawn.
- Prioritize a high-quality circular polarizer filter to cut glare from waterfalls.
- Bring a lightweight tripod, because the f/6.3 end of that zoom will struggle without it. If you really care about sharpness, try to find a used Canon EF 16-35mm f/2.8L II USM and grab an adapter. It is built much better than the current RF budget options.
Saw your post earlier and wanted to chime in. While that 16mm is a solid tiny prime, honestly, I think you should look at the Canon RF 15-30mm f/4.5-6.3 IS STM instead. Having that extra flexibility in Iceland is actually a lifesaver because you cant always physically move to frame the shot near those cliffs and waterfalls.
- The stabilization is a huge plus since you might be shooting handheld in some dim light.
- Youre getting 15mm, which is noticeably wider than 16mm for those epic landscape shots.
- It balances pretty well on the R8 body, so it wont feel too front-heavy. Check out the reviews on DPReview if you want to pixel peep the sharpness. Even if it costs a bit more, you really wont regret having the zoom range for landscapes. Totally worth the extra budget imo.