What is the best all-around zoom lens for Panasonic L-mount?

Question

Ive been a Lumix shooter forever but mostly stuck to the MFT stuff like the GH5 but I finally took the plunge on an S5II because I got this big wedding shoot booked for next month in Tahoe and Im honestly freaking out a bit because I realized my lens kit is totally lacking for full frame. I need a workhorse zoom that can handle a bit of everything because I cant be swapping primes while the bride is walking down the aisle. I was looking at the 24-70mm S Pro but its so heavy and Im worried about my wrists after an 8 hour day. Is the Sigma 24-70mm Art II worth the weight savings or should I just stick with the Lumix 24-105mm for the extra reach and OIS? What is the best all-around zoom lens for Panasonic L-mount that wont kill my back?

Alexked · Accepted Answer

I've spent some time thinking about your situation since I read this earlier. Weddings are high-stakes environments where gear failure or physical burnout isn't an option, so you really have to be careful with balancing weight against your technical needs. I remember doing a mountain shoot once where I prioritized a heavy fast zoom, but my back and wrists gave out by the reception... it's a real risk that can ruin your focus. You might want to consider the Sigma 28-70mm f/2.8 DG DN Contemporary if you're truly worried about fatigue. It's significantly lighter than the Art series, though you lose that 24mm wide end which might be a dealbreaker for tight indoor spaces. Honestly, make sure to test how the Panasonic Lumix S 24-105mm f/4 Macro OIS handles low light before the Tahoe trip. While the OIS is great for handheld stability, that f/4 aperture can be a gamble during dim ceremonies. I would suggest bringing a fast prime as backup just in case. Better to be safe than sorry when the lighting gets tricky.

Winfredwodia · Answer

Honestly, i've been pretty disappointed with the weight of most L-mount zooms lately. Its like manufacturers forgot people actually have to carry these things for twelve hours. I used the Panasonic Lumix S PRO 24-70mm f/2.8 for a while but the ergonomics are just bad for long days. My wrist was shot after just four hours, so i wouldnt recommend it for a Tahoe wedding where you're gonna be moving around constantly. I also had some issues with third-party zooms getting dust behind the front element in the past, so even though everyone is hyping the Sigma 24-70mm f/2.8 DG DN Art II weight savings, i’m still a bit skeptical about the long-term sealing. Tahoe is incredibly dusty in the summer and you dont want that getting inside your gear during the ceremony. Your safest bet is definitely the Panasonic Lumix S 24-105mm f/4 Macro O.I.S. even though f/4 is a bit of a bummer compared to the faster glass. Its much better for a one-lens setup because:

The Dual I.S. 2 is way more reliable for handheld shots than just IBIS alone.

It covers a much more useful range for wedding ceremonies without needing a swap.

The weight wont kill your back by the time the reception starts.

Native autofocus just feels snappier when things are moving fast. I really wanted the f/2.8 options to be the holy grail, but they’re just too bulky for real-world wedding work imo. Stick with the 24-105mm and you'll probably be a lot happier... just maybe grab a cheap prime later if the reception is pitch black.

Lens Rumors

Forum

What is the best all-around zoom lens for Panasonic L-mount?