Which prime lens is best for street photography on L-mount?

Question

Ive been shooting street for ages mostly with my old M6 and manual focus lenses but honestly my eyes are getting a bit tired and I just picked up the Panasonic S5IIx for video work and decided Im gonna try it for my street stuff too since the phase detect is finally good. I thought picking a lens would be easy but there are so many options now its actually kinda paralyzing lol. Like the Sigma I-series looks so cool and tactile which I love because of the aperture rings but then there are the Panasonic 1.8 primes which are all the same size and weight which is super handy for gimbal work if I swap.

Im moving to Tokyo in three weeks for a two month personal project and I need something fast and reliable for those crowded Shinjuku alleys. My budget is roughly $900 give or take for this one. I used to be a 35mm purist but lately 50mm has been calling my name for tighter portraits of people in the crowds. Im looking for something that isnt a total brick because I walk like 15 miles a day when Im out there. Should I go for the Sigma 35mm f2 or maybe that new Lumix 35mm or should I just go 50mm and call it a day? What are you guys using on your L-mount bodies for street stuff these days?

Kerwfat · Accepted Answer

^ This. Also, dont sleep on the weight factor because those Shinjuku days are long. I remember lugging a heavy zoom through Golden Gai once and my shoulder was basically screaming by 10 PM. Switching to a small prime totally changed how much I actually enjoyed the process. Since you are coming from manual rangefinders, you will probably find the Sigma 35mm f2 DG DN Contemporary feels more right in your hands. The build quality is dense and that aperture ring lets you set exposure without even looking at the screen. But the Panasonic Lumix S 35mm f1.8 is significantly lighter which matters when you are hitting those 15-mile targets.Autofocus: Panasonic lenses have a tiny edge for video because they use a linear motor system that is basically silent.Weather sealing: Both are decent, but the Panasonic primes are surprisingly rugged for being mostly high-grade plastic.Consistency: If you grab the Panasonic Lumix S 50mm f1.8 too, you can swap them on your S5IIx without touching your ND filters or gimbal settings. I personally went with the Sigma I-series because I missed that tactile click from my film days. There is just something about the way the Sigma 35mm f2 DG DN Contemporary renders light that feels more classic than the clinical look of the Lumix glass. Its a trade-off between pure efficiency and the feel of the shooting process tho... if you want that 50mm look for portraits, the Sigma 65mm f2 DG DN Contemporary is also a sleeper hit for street stuff.

Spinnerel · Answer

Tokyo is honestly a dream for street stuff, especially those narrow alleys in Shinjuku. I have spent a lot of time shooting there over the years and having a fast setup is key. In my experience, if you are coming from that M6 background, you are really gonna appreciate the build of the Sigma lenses. I have tried many different brands on my L-mount bodies, but Sigma just nails that tactile feel. Just get any of those Sigma metal primes and you will be set. They feel like real tools rather than plastic toys. If you are worried about the weight for those 15 mile days tho, the Panasonic primes are probably a safer bet. They are so light you barely feel them on the camera. Honestly, go with Sigma if you want the soul, or Panasonic if you want the utility. Both brands are killing it right now for the S5IIx. Have an amazing trip, you are gonna get some incredible shots!

Lens Rumors

Forum

Which prime lens is best for street photography on L-mount?