Finally got my S5II for a Japan trip next month and I'm so hyped! I saw the Sigma 24-70 is amazing but it looks massive for walking all day, then people mention the 28-200 but I worry about the low light performance. What is the best all-around zoom lens for L-mount that balances everything?
I've run through dozens of lenses over the years. Honestly, the Sigma 28-70mm f/2.8 DG DN Contemporary L-Mount is the sweet spot. It's only 470g. Compare that to the massive Art version... no contest. I carried one through Osaka last year and didnt miss the 24mm wide end at all. Quick tip: map the APS-C crop to a button for instant 105mm reach.
I totally get the struggle. Over the years I've hauled heavy glass through Tokyo and Kyoto, and honestly, weight is the silent killer of a good vacation. I definitely agree with you about that 24-70 size; it's a total beast to carry all day. In my experience, the massive zooms are incredible for professional gigs but they kinda ruin the vibe when you're just trying to enjoy the scenery. A few things I always consider for travel:
- total weight with the body
- how it balances on a strap
- weather sealing for those random showers I've tried many setups and a lighter lens usually wins for me every time. You might lose a stop of light, but your back will thank you when you're climbing stairs at Fushimi Inari... dont underestimate the fatigue factor.
Like someone mentioned, the Sigma 28-70 is a solid choice for weight, but i gotta respectfully disagree about skipping the wide end. In my experience shooting in cities like Tokyo, those narrow alleys and massive temples really demand something wider than 28mm. Honestly, people sleep on the Panasonic LUMIX S 20-60mm f/3.5-5.6. It is dirt cheap, especially used, and having 20mm is a game changer for architecture. If you are worried about low light, the S5II handles high ISO so well that f/4 or even f/5.6 isnt the dealbreaker it used to be. Tbh, if you want the best technical balance, look at the Panasonic LUMIX S 24-105mm f/4 Macro O.I.S.. It is a bit heavier than the 20-60 but the Dual IS is insane for handheld shots at night. I've tried many combos and for a one-lens trip, having that extra reach and the 24mm wide start is usually the sweet spot for the budget. Plus the macro capability is great for food shots... hope you have a blast in Japan!
